Jeannie's sister arrives to give her a birthday present. She gives her two bottles of lotion, a white one to make her love her master more and a blue one to make her hate her enemies more. However, big sis changes the bottles and now the white one has the hate lotion and the blue one has the love lotion. After sprinkling the hate lotion on Tony, she becomes compelled to start torturing him by shrinking him and putting him in the oven. A few minutes later Roger arrives and accidentally puts the love lotion on causing Jeannie to fall for him. After some more torturing by Jeannie, her sister then arrives to claim Tony, but not until after she reveals her scheme to Tony. However, as Tony grabs the bottles, she switches them again. He then runs to Roger's apartment, which is now filled with expensive furniture and sexy female servants. When Jeannie sees Tony she puts him on a table reminiscent of the Pit and the Pendulum. Roger then mistakenly puts the hate lotion on and joins Tony